Gelotti of Caldwell


Gelotti Ice Cream started in 1984 in historic Paterson, NJ. Since day one Gelotti products have been homemade and hand packed using age old gelato making techniques and fresh ingredients. In 2001 the Sigona family opened their second Gelotti location in Caldwell, NJ. A lot has changed in 30 years. Technology, taste buds, trends, and even the emergence of the frozen yogurt fad. But through it all Gelotti has always remained a staple in North Jersey desserts. Gelotti Ice Cream hand-crafts the finest ice creams, gelatos, talian ices, and ice cream cakes. Whether you go in to order a cake, buy a few pints, or try out a scoop of a new flavor, customers can always expect a delicious experience. With a wonderful mix of flavors and dessert options, there is always something new to try. Gelotti's exciting ice cream flavors include: Almond Joy Banana Cookies & Cream Butter Pecan Cake Batter Chocolate Chip Mint Cookie Monster Peanut Butter Cup Red Velvet Strawberry Cheesecake S'mores and many more, including seasonal flavors! Along with ice cream, Gelotti is also famous for its Italian ices and gelato. With a long list of flavors, customers can find traditional favorites like cherry and lemon, as well as creative concoctions like Mountain Dew and Creamsicle. Gelotti's gelatos bring a taste of Italy to the ice cream shop, with flavors ranging from amaretto and coconut to dolce latte and Nutella.


6 Reviews
Lisa Walter
caldwell, nj

delicious ice cream...peanut free options that are delicious as well!

October 2017

Did you find this review helpful?

Jessica King Jessica King
Montclair, NJ
Best around with something for everyone!

This is, by far, one of the best ice cream/dessert establishments I've ever been to. There is literally something for everyone here. As a vegan, I am often excluded from being able to enjoy a cool treat, or dessert with a group. Gelotti has an amazing selection of vegan-friendly products to choose from, which really makes me feel great about supporting them. Not only are they vegan-friendly, they have to be one of THE tastiest creations/flavors I have ever had!!

September 2017

Did you find this review helpful?

Steph Hauser Steph Hauser
West Caldwell, NJ
Cookie Monster

Your Black Forest ice cream is my absolute favorite and my son can't get enough cookie monster

July 2017

Did you find this review helpful?

Vote Here

Gelotti of Caldwell

194 Bloomfield Ave.
Caldwell, New Jersey 07006

Phone: 973-403-9968

Visit Website

6 Reviews

Follow & Bookmarking

Bookmark this

Get Directions