2023 Best of Essex Winners - Food and Dining


Best Asian Restaurant

Gold: Umai Sushi & Steak House

18 Grove Avenue, Verona / 862-277-4125

www.umaisushinj.com

Silver: Ms. Lin Chinese Cuisine, Millburn

Bronze: SLA Thai Restaurant,

Upper Montclair

 

Best Bagel

Gold: Ike’s Bagel Cafe

277 Eisenhower Parkway, Livingston

973-369-7528 / ikesbagelcafe.net

Silver: Bagelwich Bagel Bakery & Deli, Verona

Bronze: Hot Bagels Abroad, Bloomfield

 

Best Bakery

Gold: Calandra’s Italian & French Bakery

244 US Highway 46, Fairfield  / 973-227-5008 / calandrasbakery.com

Silver: Liv Breads Artisan Bakery and Coffee Bar, Millburn

Bronze: Nicolo’s Italian Bakery and Deli, Montclair

 

Best Boutique Bakery

Gold: Jayce Baudry French Pastry

17 Church Street, Montclair

973-531-6464 / jaycebaudry.com

Silver: Sweet Kneads by Ridhima, Livingston

Bronze: Splurge Bakery, Millburn

 

Best BBQ Restaurant

Gold: The Pit Portuguese BBQ

178 Broad Street, Bloomfield / 973-743-0086 / pitnj.com

Silver: KB’s BBQ Smokehouse, Irvington

Bronze: Sweet T’s Southern Eatery, Montclair

Best Brunch/Breakfast

Gold: Il Vecchio Cafe

234 Bloomfield Avenue, Caldwell / 973-226-8889

ilvecchiocafe.com

Silver: Sweet Basil’s Cafe, Livingston

Bronze: Dolce Marie, Verona

Best Candy/Chocolate

Gold: Love Letters

2 W. Northfield Road, Livingston / 973-994-1212

lovelettrs.com

Silver: Bromilow Chocolates, West Caldwell

Bronze: Vesta Chocolate, Upper Montclair

Best Caterer

Gold: Calandra’s Italian Market & Deli

234 Bloomfield Avenue, Caldwell / 973-226-8889, ext. 3

calandrasmarketanddeli.com

Silver: Mezoco Catering, Montclair

Bronze: Eight Hills Caterers, Verona

Best Coffee/Tea

Gold: Paper Plane Coffee

61 N. Fullerton Avenue, Montclair / 973-746-2739

paperplanecoffee.com

Silver: Java Love Coffee Roasting Co., Upper Montclair

Bronze: Jola Coffee, North Caldwell

Best Deli

Gold: Calandra Italian Market & Deli

234 Bloomfield Avenue, Caldwell / 973-226-8889, ext. 3

calandrasmarketanddeli.com

Silver: Lakeside Deli, Verona

Bronze: Millburn Deli, Millburn

Best Diner

Gold: Chit Chat Diner

410 Eagle Rock Avenue West Orange

973-736-1989 / chitchatdiner.com

Silver: The Ritz Diner, Livingston

Bronze: East Hanover Diner, East Hanover

Best Event Venue

Gold: Crystal Plaza

305 W. Northfield Avenue, Livingston

973-992-8100 / crystalplazagroup.com

Silver: Cucina Calandra, Fairfield

Bronze: Blue Rose Venue, Caldwell

Best Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt

Gold: Guerriero Gelato & Cakes

194 Bloomfield Avenue, Caldwell

973-403-9968 / guerrierogelato.com

Silver: Applegate Farm, Upper Montclair

Bronze: The Towne Scoop, Verona

 

Best Italian Restaurant

Gold: Lu Nello

182 Stevens Avenue, Cedar Grove

973-837-1660 / lunellonj.com

Silver: Eleven South, Montclair

Silver: Cucina Calandra, Fairfield

Bronze: La Famiglia Ristorante & Pizzeria, Caldwell

 

Best Mediterranean Restaurant

Gold: Manouche & Company

176 Broad Street, Bloomfield

973-707-7633 / manouchenj.com

Silver: Efi’s Gyro, Montclair

Bronze: Zuegma Mediterranean Grill

Best Mexican Restaurant

Gold: Fat Fish Taco

291 Bloomfield Avenue, Caldwell

973-228-6825 / fatfishtaco.com

Silver: Benji’s Taqueria Mexican Grill, Caldwell

Bronze: Tinga Taqueria, Montclair

 

Best Other Ethnic Restaurant

Gold: Brick Lane Curry House

540 Valley Road, Upper Montclair

973-509-2100 / bricklanemontclair.com

Silver: Samba Montclair, Montclair

Bronze: Mercado, Upper Montclair

Best Outdoor Dining

Gold: Il Vecchio Cafe

234 Bloomfield Avenue, Caldwell

973-226-8889 /

Silver: Bloomfield Steak

& Seafood House, Bloomfield

Bronze: The Highlawn, West Orange

Best Private Dining Room

Gold: Calandra’s Mediterranean Grill

118 US Highway 46 East, Fairfield / 973-575-6500

calandrasmedgrill.com

Silver: Halcyon Brasserie, Montclair

Bronze: Millburn Standard, Millburn

Best Pizza

Gold: Master Pizza

379 E. Northfield Road, Livingston / 973-992-4500

masterpizzaonline.com

Silver: Teglia Pizza Bar, Montclair

Bronze: The Landmark, Livingston

Best New Restaurant

Gold: Eleven South

11 S. Fullerton Avenue, Montclair 

Silver: Nami Nori, Montclair

Bronze: Stella, Roseland

 

Best Restaurant–Full Service

Gold: Faubourg

544 Bloomfield Avenue, Montclair / 973-542-7700

faubourgmontclair.com

Silver: Cucina Calandra, Fairfield

Bronze: Bloomfield Steak and Seafood House, Bloomfield

 

Best Restaurant—BYO

Gold: Gioia Mia

331 Bloomfield Avenue, Montclair / 973-233-0350

gioiamianj.com

Silver: Bucco, Bloomfield

Bronze: Zeugma Mediterranean Grill, Montclair

 

Best Seafood Restaurant

Gold: Halcyon Brasserie

114 Walnut Street, Montclair / 973-744-4450

halcyonbrasserie.com

Silver: Jack’s Surf and Turf, Montclair

Bronze: Mama Dag’s Seafood & Pizza House, West Orange

Best Specialty Food

Gold: Calandra’s Italian Market & Deli

234 Bloomfield Avenue, Caldwell / 973-226-8889, ext. 3

calandrasmarketanddeli.com

Silver: Butler and the Board Charcuterie, Montclair

Bronze: Caldwell Marketplace, Caldwell

Best Steak

Gold: Prime 94 Steakhouse & Grill

94 Fairfield Road, Fairfield / 973-575-4555

prime94steakhouse.com

Silver: Bloomfield Steak and Seafood House, Bloomfield

Bronze: Del Monico, Cedar Grove

Best Wine/Spirit

Gold: Amanti Vino

30 Church Street, Montclair / 973-509-9463 / amantivino.com

Silver: Wine Legend, Livingston

Bronze: Angelbeck’s Fine Wine, Spirits & Beer, Upper Montclair

Best of Essex Winners 2023